Does anybody have recommendations for a drink carbonator? (like a sodastream)
My partner likes fizzy drinks. I want to get something that will last, and won’t lock us into a single vendor for refills or replacement parts.
I looked at making our own custom one - like this. We might still do something like this, but I’m also pretty clueless with this stuff and don’t want anything to explode or poison us :)
Our priorities, ordered by importance, are:
- No lock-in (adversarial interop is fine)
- Well built/long-lasting
- Convenient, safe, easy to use
Any suggestions?


My all plastic soda stream broke after 10 years of daily use. I switched to the all metal Aarke and I’ve been really happy with it. Uses the same bottle and carbonator size as soda stream.
https://aarke.us/products/carbonator-3-matte-black
That looks well made. Thanks for the link.
Thank you for the recommendation! After deliberating back and forth over whether to go with this or a DIY solution, I ended up buying this one.
I saw a tildes comment talking about this adapter. I’m thinking that, once we finish the first couple of refills, we can decide whether we want to get a bigger donor cylinder to refill them through this.
And then, if this ever does break, we can switch to a full DIY solution at that point, since we’ll then have more hands-on experience with the larger cylinders. So, we can gradually ease into a more DIY approach once we’ve shown we’ll stick with it, and have a bit more confidence.
After I got my sodastream it tasted a little off, but good enough. When I got my adapter and a 20lb co2 tank, it suddenly tasted sooooooo much better. Not sure if it’ll happen to you, but I kept the refil that came with mine as a backup for when I’m recharging my main 20lb tank.